The Finest Nanny Payroll Providers of 2023 #Imaginations Hub

The Finest Nanny Payroll Providers of 2023 #Imaginations Hub
Image source -

If you happen to just lately employed a nanny, gardener, or personal in-home nurse, the federal authorities considers you a family employer. Like some other sort of employer, family employers should withhold payroll taxes from their staff’ paychecks, pay the federal unemployment tax, and pay the employer half of an worker’s Medicare and Social Safety taxes (FICA tax).

These sophisticated monetary duties may be onerous to know, which is why many mother and father select to make use of nanny payroll software program that calculates and recordsdata payroll taxes on their behalf. Under, we record a number of the finest nanny payroll tax companies for fogeys and different family employers who would quite spend their time on one thing apart from sophisticated tax legal guidelines.

Leap to:

Finest nanny software program function comparability desk

SurePayroll HomePay GTM Payroll Providers Poppins Payroll RUN Powered by ADP
Beginning value $49.99/mo. $59/mo. $70/mo. $49/mo. Customized
Free trial 2 mos. Sure Sure 30 days Sure
Direct deposit and paper verify fee choices Direct deposit solely Sure Sure Sure Sure
Computerized tax remittance to the IRS Sure Sure Sure Sure Sure
Finish-of-year tax type preparation Sure Sure Sure Sure No
Availability in all 50 U.S. states Sure Sure Sure Sure Sure

SurePayroll: Finest general nanny payroll service

Picture: SurePayroll

SurePayroll is an inexpensive, totally featured possibility for fogeys who need each side of payroll taken off their fingers. The nanny payroll model of the corporate’s small-business payroll software program service automates tax submitting, paycheck calculation, direct deposit and state new-hire reporting (a compulsory requirement for all family employers). It additionally generates a Schedule H tax type — a.okay.a. Kind 1040 for family employment taxes — that family employers should submit with different tax types on the finish of every monetary yr.

Not like many different nanny payroll suppliers, SurePayroll doesn’t have any add-on charges for tax submitting, resembling end-of-year tax type preparation. Whereas it doesn’t have 24/7 customer support, its buyer help crew is predicated within the U.S. and is on the market evenings and weekends. You don’t need to signal a year-long contract to make use of its companies; as an alternative, you pay month to month, which provides better flexibility to family employers who rent staff seasonally.


  • Two-day direct deposit.
  • Autopilot function for payroll runs.
  • Computerized federal, state and native tax submitting.
  • Computerized state new-hire reporting.
  • Signature-ready Schedule H tax type era.


  • Low pay-as-you-go month-to-month value.
  • No add-on charges for computerized tax submitting.
  • Prolonged customer support hours, together with stay assistance on nights and weekends.
  • Simple worker self-service by way of the user-friendly SurePayroll app.


  • Buyer help isn’t out there 24/7.
  • Two-day direct deposit solely (no same-day or next-day fee choices).
  • No paper verify fee possibility.


SurePayroll expenses a flat charge of $49.99 per 30 days for its nanny payroll service. SurePayroll is likely one of the solely nanny payroll suppliers that doesn’t cost additional charges for year-end tax preparation, account setup, or tax remittance to the IRS. It additionally has a one-month free trial.

A couple of extra charges embrace multi-state tax submitting ($9.99 per extra state) and a charge for multiple worker ($10 per 30 days per additional worker).

HomePay: Finest skilled setup service

The HomePay logo.
Picture: HomePay

HomePay is a nanny payroll service owned by Together with computerized paycheck calculation and payroll tax remittance, HomePay onboards workers in your behalf. Your workers can use HomePay’s app to accrue paid break day and get reimbursed for his or her bills.

After HomePay units up your workers’ payroll accounts, your staff can contact HomePay instantly for buyer help. Employers additionally get limitless customer support in addition to assist in a possible audit. The corporate will act as your level of contact for all state tax businesses, which means it should obtain and handle all state tax notices so you will have one much less tax activity to take care of.


  • Finish-of-year tax type preparation.
  • Integration with HomePay’s time monitoring software program.
  • Computerized payroll runs.
  • State new-hire reporting.


  • Six-month money-back assure.
  • Consumer-friendly cell apps for employers and workers.
  • State tax administration.


  • No free trial.
  • Further charge for year-end tax preparation.
  • No worker profit add-ons.


HomePay begins at $59 a month for fundamental companies, which embrace worker onboarding, fundamental payroll and tax preparation and remittance. HomePay’s extra strong plan begins at $75 per 30 days, although the service is billed quarterly at $300 per quarter.

HomePay additionally expenses a further $100 charge for end-of-year tax preparation, which incorporates Schedule H, 1040, W-2, and W-3 tax-form preparation.

GTM Payroll Providers: Finest shopper schooling

The GTM logo.
Picture: GTM Payroll Providers

GTM Payroll Providers takes care of each a part of family payroll in your behalf. It additionally goes the additional mile to assist prospects perceive their new function as family employers. Academic supplies on GTM Payroll Providers’ web site embrace a free nanny paycheck calculator, data on creating an Employer Identification Quantity, a information to family staff’ rights and a listing of family employer obligations by state.

In case your U.S. state requires you to have staff’ compensation insurance coverage, GTM Payroll Providers can match you with an insurance coverage supplier and combine your premium funds together with your payroll software program. The nanny tax service may assist you to perceive legal guidelines governing staff’ compensation in your state.


  • Autopilot choice to mechanically run payroll on a schedule.
  • Guided self-service payroll onboarding by way of an internet worker portal.
  • Non-obligatory worker advantages, together with well being, imaginative and prescient, and dental insurance coverage.


  • Complete, customized buyer help with prolonged service hours.
  • Entry to CPAs, family employment professionals and payroll specialists.
  • Employees’ compensation insurance coverage add-on.
  • Thorough family employer useful resource library.


  • Six-month minimal contract required upfront.
  • Non-waivable $99 setup charge for all new shoppers.


GTM Payroll Providers begins at $70 per 30 days for one worker. Every extra worker you pay provides an additional $20 to your month-to-month value. GTM additionally has a year-end tax-filing charge of round $120, although the service is optionally available and you may put together taxes your self with no penalty.

Poppins Payroll: Finest for inexpensive nanny payroll

The Poppins Payroll logo.
Picture: Poppins Payroll

Aside from SurePayroll, Poppins Payroll has the fewest add-on charges of any nanny tax service on our best-of record. In distinction to most different payroll options, it has a 30-day free trial with out charging a sign-up charge, end-of-year tax preparation charge or direct deposit charge. Together with being one of many most cost-effective nanny payroll companies, Poppins Payroll’s nanny payroll service is extra versatile than most (for example, it gives worker fee choices like paper checks or direct deposit as an alternative of 1 or the opposite).


  • Federal Employer Identification Quantity setup.
  • Computerized state new-hire reporting.
  • PTO and sick depart monitoring.
  • Direct deposit and paper verify fee choices.


  • Useful state-by-state useful resource guides.
  • No end-of-year tax preparation charges.
  • Consumer-friendly dashboard and interface.


  • Not out there in all states.
  • No cell payroll app.


Poppins Payroll prices a $49 per 30 days flat charge, which makes it the most cost effective nanny payroll service on our record.

Run Powered by ADP: Finest for worker advantages

The ADP logo.
Picture: ADP

ADP is likely one of the greatest names in world payroll, however on prime of its enterprise-level payroll options, it has small-business payroll software program that doubles as an efficient nanny tax service. ADP’s software program product, RUN Powered by ADP, comes with a complete cell app that employers can use to run payroll from wherever and workers can use to replace their tax data and clock out and in.

Aside from its ease of use, ADP’s greatest energy is in what number of worker advantages it gives. Family employers can select from healthcare plans, 401(okay) retirement accounts and dental and imaginative and prescient medical insurance. The corporate’s 24/7 buyer help and three-month free trial additionally assist ADP stand out from the gang.

For extra data on ADP, learn our complete ADP payroll software program evaluation.


  • Direct deposit, paper verify and pay as you go debit card worker pay choices.
  • Background checks.
  • Non-obligatory retirement, medical insurance and staff’ compensation insurance coverage add-ons.
  • Time and attendance add-on.


  • A number of worker profit choices.
  • Glorious cell app with self-service onboarding for workers.
  • Extra HR options and help in comparison with most payroll software program.


  • No clear pricing on-line.
  • Further charges for some companies, together with time monitoring and W-2 and 1099 tax type preparation.


ADP doesn’t record pricing for any of its payroll software program plans on-line. Contact ADP’s customer support crew instantly for a customized quote.

HomeWork Options: Finest tax-only service possibility

The HomeWork Solutions logo.
Picture: HomeWork Options

HomeWork Options is one other nanny payroll service tailor-made instantly towards family employers. The corporate has two plans: A payroll tax-only plan that leaves paying your worker as much as you, or an entire payroll plan that mixes payroll-tax administration with worker pay administration.

HomeWork Options has add-on charges that suppliers like Poppins Payroll and SurePayroll lack, resembling a year-end tax type charge and a one-time setup charge. Moreover, should you use HWS for each tax administration and worker funds, you may solely go for weekly or biweekly pay schedules. Most different companies have free limitless payroll runs, which means you may pay your worker as many instances as you need every month with out being charged additional.


  • Robotically generated Schedule H and W-2 types.
  • Federal Employer Identification Quantity setup and state new-hire reporting.
  • Worker textual content alerts.
  • Thorough tax administration.


  • Examine fee possibility out there on request.
  • Devoted one-on-one buyer help (Full Payroll plan solely).
  • A number of plan choices, together with cheaper tax-only plan.


  • Costly plans with a number of add-on prices.
  • No free limitless payroll runs (weekly or biweekly solely).
  • No payroll app.


HomeWork Options has two plans:

  • Important Payroll: Begins at $165 per quarter. Contains tax submitting solely.
  • Full Payroll: Begins at $245 per quarter (weekly payroll) or $220 per quarter (biweekly payroll). Contains tax submitting and direct deposit.

HomeWork Options additionally expenses a number of extra charges, together with a $110 charge for year-end payroll tax submitting and a $110 setup charge for brand spanking new customers.

Paychex Flex: Finest for worker self-service

The Paychex logo.
Picture: Paychex

Paychex is a significant participant on the earth of payroll for companies, however its software program product, Paychex Flex, can work for nanny payroll too. As a full-service payroll system, Paychex calculates your family worker’s paycheck, deposits it mechanically and calculates and remits taxes to the federal government. Its stellar cell app for workers makes clocking out and in simple and provides staff fast, easy accessibility to their pay stubs and tax paperwork.

Nevertheless, since Paychex Flex is tailor-made towards small-business payroll (quite than particular to family employers), its interface could have a steep studying curve for many mother and father. Very like ADP, it additionally has much more instruments than most family employers want, particularly those that have one part-time employee quite than a fleet of dwelling workers. Nonetheless, it could be a superb choose for employers who need to provide a handful of inexpensive advantages to workers.


  • Computerized state new-hire reporting.
  • Human useful resource library entry.
  • Worker advantages like medical insurance and 401(okay) retirement accounts.
  • Integration with Paychex’s native time-tracking resolution.


  • 24/7 buyer help.
  • A number of worker pay choices, together with checks, direct deposit and pay as you go debit playing cards.
  • Devoted HR customer support consultant.


  • Further charges for some integral options, resembling tax service.
  • Steep software program studying curve for family employers.
  • Extra options than most family employers want.


Paychex has three important payroll plans for small companies and family employers:

  • Paychex Flex Necessities: Ranging from $39 per 30 days plus $5 per particular person per 30 days.
  • Paychex Flex Choose: Customized quotes solely.
  • Paychex Flex Professional: Customized quotes solely.

The primary plan, Paychex Flex Necessities, ought to have sufficient fundamental payroll options to go well with most family employers. The second- and third-tier plans are higher for employers who need to provide extra advantages with thorough HR help, although these plans are geared towards small and midsize enterprise homeowners quite than mother and father.

What are the important thing options of nanny payroll companies?

Whereas there are key variations between payroll options, most nanny payroll companies ought to embrace a mixture of the next options.

Computerized tax calculation and remittance

If you happen to’re comfy submitting taxes your self and like to economize on nanny software program, you’ll find cheaper DIY tax software program choices (and even free payroll options) that calculate paychecks and tax deduction quantities, however depart the precise submitting as much as you.

Nevertheless, determining the nanny tax is hypothetically probably the most burdensome a part of hiring a family employee. Take into account prioritizing nanny tax software program that calculates and recordsdata taxes for you.

A number of worker pay choices

Most payroll software program options embrace direct deposit as their important worker fee technique. Nevertheless, whereas direct deposit is likely one of the easiest methods to pay your workers on time, it’s not all the time the best choice for all employers and workers. If you wish to provide extra fee choices to your workers, search for software program with direct deposit, paper verify and even pay as you go debit card choices.

Time-tracking integration

Like different workers, family staff are entitled to overpay in the event that they’re paid hourly and their work week exceeds 40 hours. Time-tracking software program is the best manner for each you and your workers to verify staff are being compensated for his or her precise hours labored whereas holding you compliant with federal legislation. A while-tracking instruments additionally allow you to arrange paid break day and sick depart insurance policies primarily based in your workers’ hours labored.

Worker profit add-ons

Whereas family employers aren’t legally obligated to supply worker advantages like medical insurance and 401(okay) retirement plans, some select to supply advantages to draw prime expertise or retain workers.

Buyer help

Your nanny payroll firm’s buyer help crew must be out there to assist each you and your family workers. Ideally, your crew is on the market around the clock or else on an prolonged schedule that features weeknights and a few weekend hours. You may additionally contemplate selecting a nanny tax service that works instantly together with your workers to arrange their time monitoring and payroll software program.

Worker self-service portals

Staff must entry their tax information, hours labored, pay stubs and direct deposit data. Often, probably the most handy manner for them to take action is thru a cell app, or at the very least by way of a mobile-friendly web site. Whether or not by way of an app or web site, workers ought to be capable to handle their very own information independently.

Nanny payroll tax overview

Usually talking, the one family employment taxes you must fear about are the next two:

  • FICA taxes, which embrace Social Safety and Medicare taxes.
  • FUTA taxes, or federal unemployment insurance coverage taxes, that are paid for by employers (not workers).

Together with accurately withholding their workers’ FICA taxes and remitting them to the federal authorities, employers should match their workers’ FICA taxes greenback for greenback.

For the 2023 tax yr, the Social Safety tax charge is 6.2% whereas the Medicare tax charge is 1.45%. You’ll must match no matter greenback quantity your worker’s tax charge provides as much as with every paycheck.

Employers are additionally accountable for paying FUTA taxes, that are unemployment insurance coverage taxes. These taxes are paid solely by employers, not by their workers. You might also must pay a state unemployment insurance coverage tax relying on which state you reside in.

Nanny payroll tax software program will help you calculate FICA taxes, together with the worker and employer portion of the tax, in addition to FUTA taxes, then deposit these taxes by their tax fee deadlines.

Whereas family employers don’t need to withhold and file revenue taxes for his or her workers, your worker may as you to take action. Nanny payroll companies can sometimes assist you to deal with this activity as nicely.

How can I select the correct nanny payroll service for my family?

The precise payroll software program in your family will rely upon a wide range of key concerns. First, ask your self how a lot you’re prepared and in a position to pay for a nanny tax service. Don’t overlook to look into sneaky add-on charges, particularly setup and end-of-year tax-filing prices, and embrace these in your general nanny payroll funds.

Subsequent, have a look at options. Would you quite have software program that mechanically runs payroll on a pre-set schedule, or would you like to run payroll your self every pay interval so you may double-check for accuracy? Do you worth instruments like cell payroll apps, or are you cheerful sufficient with an internet interface solely? Asking these kinds of questions will help you slender down which payroll software program is best for you.


To put in writing this piece, we solely checked out enterprise payroll software program with family employment choices and at nanny payroll-only corporations. We then ranked our payroll software program picks utilizing the next components:

  • Worth, particularly whether or not the variety of options warranted the associated fee and whether or not there have been any add-on charges.
  • Nanny payroll options like Schedule H type era, FUTA tax administration and family employer HR assets.
  • Normal payroll software program options like direct deposit, free limitless payroll runs and cell payroll instruments.
  • Ease of use, customer support hours and availability, dashboard and consumer interface, tax accuracy ensures and extra.

To collect this data, we talked to customer support reps to get pricing and plan data, totally reviewed every supplier’s web site, learn combination buyer opinions and regarded demos and YouTube how-to movies at any time when they had been out there.

Ceaselessly requested questions

Why do I would like nanny payroll companies?

If you happen to make use of a nanny, the IRS considers you a family employer, which suggests you’re accountable for withholding key payroll taxes out of your nanny’s paycheck. You could additionally pay employer-only taxes, such because the employer portion of Medicare and Social Safety taxes, plus federal and state unemployment taxes.

Understanding these new tax obligations may be difficult at finest, as can getting ready and submitting the proper quarterly and end-of-year tax types. A nanny payroll service will mechanically calculate your nanny’s payroll taxes. Essentially the most complete nanny payroll software program will even withhold and remit these taxes to the federal authorities on the suitable cadence.

Most nanny payroll companies additionally put together essential end-of-year tax types, although most cost a further charge for tax type preparation. (Poppins Payroll and SurePayroll, which don’t cost additional for end-of-year tax type prep, are key exceptions.) Moreover, nanny payroll software program sometimes calculates nanny paychecks and pays your family worker mechanically by way of direct deposit or paper verify.

Briefly, having a nanny payroll service can make sure you pay your nanny on time and fulfill your new tax obligations with as little stress as attainable.

Can I take advantage of an everyday payroll service for my nanny?

No. Common payroll companies are meant for companies, not households, and don’t provide the options family employers must pay their workers. Some common payroll suppliers, resembling Paychex and SurePayroll, provide nanny-payroll variations of their common software program. Different nanny payroll suppliers, resembling HomePay and HomeWork Options, are nanny-payroll particular.

Ought to I give my nanny a W-2 type or 1099 type?

It is best to give your nanny a W-2 type, not a 1099 type, after they first begin working for you.

How do I arrange payroll for my nanny?

Step one to establishing payroll in your nanny is to use for an employer identification quantity on-line. You also needs to have your nanny fill out a W-2 type.

The best method to arrange payroll in your nanny is by subscribing to a nanny payroll service. Many nanny payroll companies automate each side of paying a nanny or different in-house worker, together with calculating paychecks, paying your nanny by way of direct deposit and submitting employment taxes regularly.

Related articles

You may also be interested in